(Note: these learning modules encompass the
actual class lectures, and are designed for those students who have to miss class
through no fault of their own, and also as a refresher for all students. Bold
print in the notes are what the professor writes on the board.)
LEARNING MODULE: WEEKS 5-6, Political Parties
Why do we even have
political parties? They’re not mentioned in the Constitution. Many of the
Founding Fathers distrusted them, regarding them as “factions,” which is
defined as citizens united in a common purpose that is opposed to other
citizens. In other words, self-interested, selfish. President Washington in his
Farewell Address warned against the emergence of political parties. He had
viewed himself as so public-spirited that he was above selfish interests, and
he didn’t appreciate having his foreign policy (favored by the Federalists)
blasted by the new Republican Party (not related to the current Republican
Party). Yet can any real democracy survive with no political parties, or with
only one political party? Some Founders might have thought that they were so
public-spirited that they didn’t need any opposition, but they were a higher
socioeconomic status group who were all white men. What about having only one
party? Has that worked anywhere in the world in recent history? Let’s see- the
Communist Soviet Union, Putin’s Russia, the “People’s” Republic of China. The
list goes on.
So, it is good that
we have had two political parties throughout our nation’s history. Why not have
three, or four, or five? Well, look at Italy, Israel, and other multi-party
systems. They have to come up with a majority coalition of enough parties
to be able to select their Prime Minister (their chief executive). Whenever one
of their parties gets upset and leaves the coalition, new elections are held,
sometimes more than one election in a year. Very unstable situation.
Can a two-party
system be harmful to citizens? Sure. Look at what we are living through
right now. Many Democrats hate Trump with a passion. Many Republicans hated
Biden and Obama. Every year it’s something new- Russian collusion, obstruction
of justice, Ukraine aid, Coronavirus, the Capital riots, and now mass
deportations. When Obama was President, Fox News Sean Hannity would attack
anything that he did, and political newcomer Donald Trump even claimed that Obama
wasn’t even born in the United States and that he was a Muslim (actually, his
father met those criteria), and one GOP (Republican) Congressman screamed out
“Liar” during one of his State of the Union Addresses. In Trump’s first term,
only one Democratic congress member (Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia) was
even willing to shake his hand after the State of the Union address, the House
Democratic Speaker Nancy Pelosi even tore up his speech. So why are things so
divisive today? Well, we used to have two political parties that were very
ideologically diverse. As late as the 1960s the Democrats did have many
conservative southerners in their party, and the Republicans had many liberal
and moderate northerners in their party. But then the two parties realigned
themselves along strict ideological lines, as conservative southern Democrats
fled to the Republican Party, and northern Republicans who weren’t conservative
fled to the Democratic Party. Oddly enough, the political science professors in
their national association in 1950 had applauded such a “responsible party
system” where the two parties would stand for very distinct and different
ideologies, since the professors liked this more British Parliamentary system.
Well, they got their wish! Thanks for nothing!!
So what do you all
think about our current political party system, and what we are living through?
Any way to improve the situation?
America has had a
two-party system throughout its history, but only since the Civil War have we
had the current parties- the Democrats and Republicans. Our history can be
divided into six different political eras, and the first two pre-Civil War eras
were so unsettled that the names of the parties were different. The parties
typically differed in terms of economic interests (agriculture versus
business), region (South versus Northeast), and other issues. Since most
Americans were farmers before the Civil War, the more pro-agriculture party,
which was stronger in the South, was the dominant party.
The first party
system was from 1796 thru 1828. The Federalists favored a stronger
central government to promote business expansion, were more elitist, liked
Great Britain, and were based in the northeast. The Republicans (no relation to
current party) were for states’ rights since they favored an agricultural
republic, liked republican France, were strong in the South, and won every
presidential election beginning in 1800. The “elitist” Federalists died out,
after supporting “anti-democratic” Alien, Sedition, and Naturalization Acts
during Federalist John Adams’ administration, and after opposing the War of
1812 against Britain.
The second party
system was from 1828-1860. By 1824 with everyone running as a
Republican, that party split into two factions- the National Republicans and
the Democratic Republicans. The latter faction won in 1828 with Andrew Jackson
as president, and they shortened their name to Democratic. Democrats were like
the old Republican Party, as they were pro-agriculture and strong in the South.
Jackson was a strong president, who vetoed the national bank, removed the
Indians, defied a Supreme Court decision, and opposed South Carolina’s nullification
of a federal tariff, so his opponents unified into the Whig Party (named after
the anti-monarchy party of Britain). Jackson was also a great believer in the
Common Man (common white man), unlike the well-educated elitist Virginia
Dynasty of presidents Jefferson, Madison, and Monroe. So during this era, the
franchise expanded to include all adult white males (even those without money
or property), more public offices became elected instead of appointed
(including presidential electors), and parties began holding national
conventions to select their presidential nominees (instead of just letting the
King Caucus, congress members of that party pick them). Democrats were the
dominant party. They wisely reached out to new immigrant groups who were Catholics,
and they supported territorial expansion (war with Mexico, gaining the
southwest territory, a popular stance in the South).
Hopefully, someone
has picked the American Lion to report on. Now’s a good time to report on it,
if you’ve had a chance to get it and finish it.
The third-party
system was from 1860-1896. Well, the Whigs were a national party, so the
bitter slavery issue tore them up, and they ceased to exist. The Democrats, who
had had two Presidents in the 1850s who were labeled “northern men of southern
principles”, were dominant in the South. A new political party opposed to
slavery arose in the North and was dominant there; they were the modern
Republican Party. This party was also very pro-business expansion and
pro-industrialization. So we had two very regional parties, and when the
Republican (Lincoln) won, the South seceded from the union. This Third party
system was a simple one- the anti-slavery and pro-business Republican Party
versus the more pro-agriculture Democrats who were sympathetic to the white
Southern way of life. Like the current era, there was no real majority party,
as presidential elections were really close; Republican presidents usually won
and controlled the Senate, but Democrats had so many safe seats in the South
that they usually controlled the House.
Thought question- do you think are country is as
divided today as it was in the late 1850s? Look at how many lawsuits more
liberal and Democratic states have filed against the Trump administration, and how
many Republican-controlled states filed against Biden administration
initiatives. Indeed, California will have a ballot initiative in 2028 on
whether it should become an independent nation! If other West Coast and
Northeast states joined them, we could have two nations- the United Red States
of America, and the Disunited Blue States of America. Kind of like colonial
British India after World War 2, divided into Hindu India and Muslim West and
East Pakistan (now Bangladesh, a third country). Crazy Shaffer, never could
happen. Funny, a U.S. News and World Report article in the 1970s talked about
how ethnic diversity in the Soviet Union could break up that superpower, and we
all laughed and said, never will happen.
Well, now we come
to the last three party eras (including the Progressive Era), which are easy to
ask a question about on the midterm essay exam.
The fourth party system
from 1896-1932 started when the Democrats nominated the Populist William
Jennings Bryan, who was so totally pro-farmer (for inflation to help debtor
farmers, for example) that businessmen were terrified and warned their workers
that they wouldn’t have jobs if he won. “We will not be crucified on a cross of
gold,” Bryan screamed, as he opposed the hard money gold standard, and wanted
free coinage of silver. Democrats made the mistake of nominating him for
President three times, so Republicans became the majority party in America.
Republicans were very pro-business and were strong in the northeast and
Midwest. Democrats were pro-agriculture and largely confined to the South.
Republicans won every presidential election except for 1912 when Democrat Woodrow
Wilson won (previous Republican President Theodore Roosevelt disliked the
current Republican President Howard Taft, so they both ran in the general
election and split the Republican vote) and in 1916 when Wilson won re-election
as a safe choice right before World War 1.
The Progressive Era
during this party era was a middle-class reform movement that opposed powerful
interests, such as big businesses and political bosses, and sought good honest
government. It was so popular that both parties supported it- Republican Teddy
Roosevelt and Democrat Wilson were both progressives. Progressives enacted an
amendment requiring that states let the people vote for their U.S. Senators
(bypassing state legislatures controlled by dominant businesses in the states),
plus an amendment requiring that they permit women (believed to be more civic
minded) to vote. States enacted voter registration laws to combat voter fraud,
and required parties to hold primary elections to select their nominees
(striking at the power of party bosses who dominated the old convention-caucus nominating
system). Progressive policies included trust busting (breaking up business
monopolies), conservation (national parks created), and a federal
constitutional amendment permitting a federal income tax. This new tax was very
important in starting the expansion of the federal government.
The fifth party system
from 1932-1968 started when the stock market crashed, and our nation was
plunged into the Great Depression. Since this happened on Republican President Herbert
Hoover’s watch and during a Republican-controlled Congress, people voted for a
change and Democrat Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) was elected. With 25%
unemployment and so many people losing their jobs, their homes, and their life
savings, Roosevelt’s liberal economic programs called the New Deal were very
popular. They included: public jobs for the unemployed; welfare (Aid to
Families with Dependent Children); a federal minimum wage; the Wagner Act
protecting workers’ rights to join labor unions; Social Security; farm crop
price supports. So added to the party’s traditional strength among Catholics
(dating back to Jackson’s era) and white Southerners (due to the Civil War),
Democrats now gained the support of the low income, blue-collar workers, most
African Americans (where they could vote), liberals, Jews (historically liberal
due to their oppression in Europe), intellectuals (fascinated by the
possibilities of an active federal government), and most average Americans. Not
only did FDR win four terms, but Republicans were only able to elect the war
hero Eisenhower as President during this era. Democrats dominated the Congress
for all except four years. Republicans kept getting attacked as the party of
the rich and big business, and Democrats were liberal only on the popular
economic issues.
The sixth party era is
from 1968 to the present time. There is no majority party. So what
happened to the Democrats? Well, they
became a consistently liberal party on all issues, not just economics, and the
non-economic issues were more controversial and divisive. When Democrats became
the majority party they finally had a lot of support in the north, so
northerners looked at the segregated racial system of the South and said,
enough is enough. Their national convention in 1948 adopted a civil rights
plank, and Presidents Kennedy and Johnson vigorously fought to enact the 1964
Civil Rights Act and the 1965 Voting Rights Act. Republicans meanwhile became
more consistently conservative, nominating conservative Barry Goldwater from
Arizona as their presidential nominee in 1964. Those events started the exodus
of white southerners from the Democratic Party. That 1964 election between
Goldwater and Johnson also started African Americans voting 90% Democratic.
Then, the Democrats became viewed as more liberal on cultural and crime issues,
being sympathetic to the protesters and rioters of the 1960s (who opposed
police brutality, the Vietnam War, our traditional society), so Republican
Nixon got elected president in 1968. The Democrats have also become pro-choice
on the abortion issue which feminists liked, and pro-gay (LGBTQ) rights which
was controversial among most voters until the Obama years. Democrats also
became viewed as soft on national defense with the AFL-CIO refusing to endorse
liberal McGovern in 1972 (so Nixon won re-election) and with Jimmy Carter
“losing Iran” (and losing to Reagan in 1980). So Democrats lost a lot of
support, and they lost their majority. But Republicans have not been able to
become the new majority party. Republicans still have the problem of being
perceived as the party of the rich, and of big business. They have also
absorbed the Religious Right, so many view them as intolerant on women’s
issues, gay issues, even racial issues. Trump’s anti-DEI (diversity, equity,
inclusion) and his mass deportations of undocumented immigrants are also
controversial stances.
American politics today are a real cliff hanger.
In the twenty-five years of this century, Democrats Obama has won twice and
Biden once, Republicans have won four times, but in both 2000 and 2016 the
Republican (Bush, Trump) lost the national popular vote while winning election
with an electoral college majority. Biden’s three predecessors have had a
Congress where both chambers were controlled by their party for only two years
each! Biden and Trump’s 2nd term did have their parties controlling
both chambers of Congress, but Biden lost the House majority in his midterm
election, and Trump may have a similar problem. Indeed, the current party
lineup is only 53 Republicans (and 3 often defect) and 47 Democrats in the
Senate, and 220 Republicans and 213 Democrats (2 vacancies) in the House. So,
what an exciting time to live in. Trump is not a typical Republican, he won
blue-collar workers in critical Midwest states with his pro-jobs and trade war
policies. But his rhetoric is controversial and divisive. His job approval
rating was always below 50%, as it is today (such ratings predicted his
re-election defeat in 2020). But Biden’s ratings were also not very high, generally
below 50%. So, should be an exciting semester! Which of these two political
parties do you think will win the 2026 midterm congressional elections and the
next presidential election?? Which party do you prefer to win, and why?